Every winter in Southeastern Massachusetts, the ground freezes, thaws, and freezes again, sometimes several times in one week. Water in the soil expands as it turns to ice and lifts whatever is sitting on top of it. That movement is the single biggest factor in how long a patio lasts here.
Poured concrete is one rigid slab. When the ground under it moves unevenly, the slab can't flex, so it cracks. Control joints help steer where the cracks go, but they don't stop them, and a cracked slab can't really be repaired invisibly. De-icing salt and repeated freezing can also flake the surface over time.
Pavers handle movement differently. A paver patio is hundreds of individual units with sand-filled joints between them, so the surface can shift slightly and settle back without breaking. If a section does sink years later, those pavers can be lifted, the base corrected, and the same pavers put back. You repair a few square feet instead of replacing a slab.
The part that matters most is underneath either one. A paver patio on a thin, poorly compacted base will heave and dip just like bad concrete cracks. The base needs to be excavated deep enough, built up in compacted layers, and pitched so water drains away rather than sitting under the surface.
If you're comparing estimates, ask each contractor how deep they excavate, what the base is made of, and how they handle drainage. Those answers tell you more about how the patio will look in ten years than the paver color does.
